SWD Protocol Initialization and Deprecated Sequence Observation
The SWD (Serial Wire Debug) protocol is a two-pin interface used for debugging ARM Cortex-M microcontrollers, including the STM32F103. During the initialization phase of the SWD protocol, the debugger (in this case, JLink EDU) communicates with the target device to establish a connection. This process involves several distinct phases, including the transmission of specific sequences to switch from JTAG to SWD mode. One such sequence is the deprecated sequence, which appears as "0110110110110111" (0xEDB6) on the SWDIO line.
The deprecated sequence is a legacy sequence that was used in earlier versions of the SWD protocol to ensure that the SWJ-DP (Serial Wire Debug and JTAG Debug Port) is correctly switched to SW-DP (Serial Wire Debug Port) mode. Although this sequence is no longer required in modern implementations, some debuggers, like the JLink EDU, still send it to maintain compatibility with older devices or to ensure that the switch to SWD mode is successful.
The observation of the deprecated sequence raises several questions: Why is this sequence still being sent? Is it necessary for all devices? How does it affect the debugging process? To answer these questions, we need to delve deeper into the SWD protocol, the role of the deprecated sequence, and its implications for debugging STM32F103 microcontrollers.
Memory Barrier Omission and Cache Invalidation Timing
The deprecated sequence in the SWD protocol is a remnant of earlier implementations where the transition from JTAG to SWD mode was less standardized. In modern ARM Cortex-M processors, including the STM32F103, the SWD protocol has been refined, and the deprecated sequence is no longer required. However, some debuggers still send this sequence to ensure compatibility with a wide range of devices, including those that might still rely on the older protocol.
One possible reason for the continued use of the deprecated sequence is the omission of memory barriers or improper cache invalidation timing during the initialization phase. Memory barriers are used to ensure that memory operations are completed in the correct order, which is crucial during the transition from JTAG to SWD mode. If memory barriers are omitted, the debugger might send the deprecated sequence as a precautionary measure to ensure that the SWJ-DP is correctly switched to SW-DP mode.
Another factor to consider is the timing of cache invalidation. In ARM Cortex-M processors, the cache must be invalidated before switching to SWD mode to ensure that the debugger has access to the correct memory regions. If the cache invalidation is not timed correctly, the debugger might send the deprecated sequence to force the switch to SWD mode, even if it is not strictly necessary.
Implementing Data Synchronization Barriers and Cache Management
To address the issue of deprecated sequences in the SWD protocol, it is essential to implement proper data synchronization barriers and cache management techniques. Data synchronization barriers ensure that all memory operations are completed before proceeding to the next instruction, which is crucial during the transition from JTAG to SWD mode. By inserting data synchronization barriers at the appropriate points in the initialization sequence, the debugger can ensure that the SWJ-DP is correctly switched to SW-DP mode without the need for deprecated sequences.
Cache management is another critical aspect of the SWD protocol initialization. Before switching to SWD mode, the cache must be invalidated to ensure that the debugger has access to the correct memory regions. This can be achieved by using the appropriate cache invalidation instructions, such as the Data Cache Invalidate by Virtual Address (DC IVAC) instruction in ARM Cortex-M processors. By ensuring that the cache is invalidated at the correct time, the debugger can avoid sending deprecated sequences and streamline the initialization process.
In addition to data synchronization barriers and cache management, it is also important to consider the configuration of the SWJ-DP. The SWJ-DP can be configured to use either JTAG or SWD mode, and the configuration must be set correctly before the debugger can establish a connection. This can be done by writing to the appropriate registers in the SWJ-DP, such as the DP Control/Status Register (DP_CTRL/STAT). By ensuring that the SWJ-DP is correctly configured, the debugger can avoid sending deprecated sequences and improve the overall efficiency of the debugging process.
Detailed Analysis of SWD Protocol Initialization
To better understand the role of the deprecated sequence in the SWD protocol, let’s take a closer look at the initialization process. The SWD protocol initialization consists of several phases, each of which plays a crucial role in establishing a connection between the debugger and the target device.
The first phase of the SWD protocol initialization is the line reset phase. During this phase, the debugger drives the SWDIO line high for a specified number of cycles to reset the SWD interface. This is followed by the transmission of the SWD switch sequence, which is used to switch the SWJ-DP from JTAG to SWD mode. The SWD switch sequence consists of a specific pattern of bits that is recognized by the SWJ-DP and causes it to switch to SWD mode.
After the SWD switch sequence, the debugger sends the deprecated sequence, which is a legacy sequence that was used in earlier versions of the SWD protocol. This sequence is no longer required in modern implementations, but some debuggers still send it to ensure compatibility with older devices or to force the switch to SWD mode. The deprecated sequence is followed by a series of idle cycles, during which the SWDIO line is driven high to allow the SWJ-DP to complete the switch to SWD mode.
Once the SWJ-DP has switched to SWD mode, the debugger sends a READID command to read the IDCODE register of the target device. The IDCODE register contains information about the target device, including its part number and revision. By reading the IDCODE register, the debugger can verify that the connection has been established successfully and that the target device is ready for debugging.
Potential Issues with Deprecated Sequences
While the deprecated sequence is not required in modern implementations of the SWD protocol, its presence can still cause issues in certain scenarios. One potential issue is the increased initialization time. The deprecated sequence adds additional cycles to the initialization process, which can delay the establishment of the connection between the debugger and the target device. This can be particularly problematic in time-sensitive applications where fast initialization is critical.
Another potential issue is the increased power consumption. The deprecated sequence requires additional signaling on the SWDIO line, which can increase the power consumption of the target device. This can be a concern in low-power applications where minimizing power consumption is a priority.
Finally, the deprecated sequence can cause compatibility issues with certain devices. While most modern ARM Cortex-M processors, including the STM32F103, are compatible with the deprecated sequence, some older devices might not recognize it. This can result in a failed initialization and prevent the debugger from establishing a connection with the target device.
Best Practices for SWD Protocol Initialization
To avoid the issues associated with deprecated sequences, it is important to follow best practices for SWD protocol initialization. These best practices include:
-
Use Modern Debuggers: Modern debuggers, such as the JLink EDU, are designed to work with the latest versions of the SWD protocol and do not require the use of deprecated sequences. By using a modern debugger, you can ensure that the initialization process is streamlined and efficient.
-
Configure the SWJ-DP Correctly: Before starting the initialization process, ensure that the SWJ-DP is correctly configured to use SWD mode. This can be done by writing to the appropriate registers in the SWJ-DP, such as the DP Control/Status Register (DP_CTRL/STAT).
-
Implement Data Synchronization Barriers: Data synchronization barriers ensure that all memory operations are completed before proceeding to the next instruction. By inserting data synchronization barriers at the appropriate points in the initialization sequence, you can ensure that the SWJ-DP is correctly switched to SWD mode without the need for deprecated sequences.
-
Manage Cache Invalidation: Before switching to SWD mode, ensure that the cache is invalidated to allow the debugger to access the correct memory regions. This can be achieved by using the appropriate cache invalidation instructions, such as the Data Cache Invalidate by Virtual Address (DC IVAC) instruction in ARM Cortex-M processors.
-
Monitor Initialization Timing: Monitor the timing of the initialization process to ensure that it is completed within the required timeframe. This can be done using an oscilloscope or logic analyzer to observe the SWDIO and SWCLK signals during the initialization process.
By following these best practices, you can ensure that the SWD protocol initialization process is efficient, reliable, and free from the issues associated with deprecated sequences.
Conclusion
The deprecated sequence in the SWD protocol is a legacy sequence that is no longer required in modern implementations. However, some debuggers, such as the JLink EDU, still send this sequence to ensure compatibility with older devices or to force the switch to SWD mode. While the deprecated sequence is generally harmless, it can cause issues such as increased initialization time, higher power consumption, and compatibility problems with certain devices.
To avoid these issues, it is important to follow best practices for SWD protocol initialization, including using modern debuggers, configuring the SWJ-DP correctly, implementing data synchronization barriers, managing cache invalidation, and monitoring initialization timing. By following these best practices, you can ensure that the SWD protocol initialization process is efficient, reliable, and free from the issues associated with deprecated sequences.
In summary, the deprecated sequence is a relic of earlier SWD protocol implementations and is not required for modern ARM Cortex-M processors like the STM32F103. By understanding the role of the deprecated sequence and following best practices for SWD protocol initialization, you can streamline the debugging process and avoid potential issues.
